Absurdly soft & moist Dutch cocoa cake layers, smooth & fluffy coffee Oreo cream cheese buttercream, rich chocolate ganache with big hunks of Oreo, and the most luscious salted bourbon butterscotch drip. Aka MY ultimate birthday cake.
I’m aware we’re currently in the season of turkey, sweet potatoes, and pumpkin pie. But we’re also deep in scorpio season, which, for many of us, means BIRTHDAY CAKE season. Thus, I present my favorite combination of flavors in my ultimate birthday cake.
chocolate
cookies & cream
coffee
chocolate
sea salt
bourbon
butterscotch
more cookies
more chocolate
There is so much about this cake that makes it special. The flavors are beautiful and perfectly balanced with deep Dutch cocoa, dark chocolate, sweet cookies, tangy cream cheese, and salty, nutty, caramely, bourbony butterscotch. Even more than that, the textures are everything in this cake. In every bite, you get the softest, moistest chocolate sponge, super creamy and fluffy cream cheese buttercream, truffle-textured chocolate ganache that melts in your mouth, big crunchy wafers, and silky butterscotch that drips like liquid gold.
It should go without saying that this cake is MIND-BLOWING. Mouth-watering. Show-stopping. Crowd-pleasing thrilling. Decadently delicious. My favorite ever. Period. And it’s not even difficult to make!
the cake
- This recipe makes a small-batch 6-inch cake in 3 tall layers. With the cream cheese buttercream, ganache, and Oreos to build it up, I’ve found this size to be more than enough for a party. I also really love the triple-layer design for the alternating soft, creamy, crunchy, and melty textures balanced in every bite.
- If you only have 8-inch cake pans, you can adapt the recipe to make 2 layers (will be slightly thinner, lean toward lower cooking time). Or, you can double the cake recipe for 3 layers of 8-inch cakes (lean toward longer cooking time).
- While cocoa is naturally acidic, Dutch cocoa is alkalinized, resulting in a smoother chocolatey flavor (think devil’s food cake). Look for any unsweetened cocoa “processed with alkali.” It may be called Dutch, black, or Ghirardelli’s “majestic” cocoa.
- A combo of buttermilk and sour cream gives the cake full flavor, excellent rise, and super soft texture, and incredible moisture.
- Using neutral oil (such as refined almond oil, vegetable oil, or coconut oil) rather than butter helps the cake retain even more moisture.
- Instant espresso enhances the chocolate flavor of the cake without making it taste like coffee. If you’re like me and do want to bring out espresso flavor, we’ll add it in the cream cheese frosting.
- Extra baking soda (sodium bicarb) is important for the optimal reaction with acidic buttermilk and sour cream and the fluffiest result.
the fillings
- COFFEE OREO CREAM CHEESE BUTTERCREAM. It’s beautifully creamy and fluffy with yummy cookies & cream flavor plus a hint of flavorful espresso and vanilla.
- Dark chocolate ganache. High-quality dark chocolate is simply melted together with hot heavy cream and stirred to smooth, rich, luscious chocolatey perfection. It will be thick and dense at room temperature and harden at lower temperatures. I love this cake out of the fridge for the cold firm chocolate center. At any temperature, the ganache MELTS IN YOUR MOUTH like a decadent truffle.
- Oreo pieces. You know when you take a bite of anything cookies & cream and crunch into a HUGE hunk of Oreo and think, “YES, I WON”? So, why not make a dessert where you guarantee a WIN in every bite? That’s the idea here. YOU WIN.
the drip
- Butterscotch is one of my absolute favorite complementary flavors, and it tastes magical against the dark chocolate and tangy cream cheese in this cake. It’s made with dark brown sugar for a warm, nutty molasses flavor. (Caramel, on the other hand, is made with white sugar.) A splash of bourbon and bite of sea salt take it to the next level. At room temperature, the texture is perfectly thick, glossy, and just runny enough for a mesmerizing drip.
Absurdly soft & moist Dutch cocoa cake layers, smooth & fluffy coffee Oreo cream cheese buttercream, rich chocolate ganache with big hunks of Oreo, and the most luscious salted bourbon butterscotch drip. Aka MY ultimate birthday cake in a small-batch, 6-inch, triple-layer design. Generously serves 8-12 people. This recipe makes a small-batch 6-inch, 3-layer cake. If you only have 8-inch cake pans, you can use this recipe for an 8-inch, 2-layer cake (cakes will be slightly thinner, so lean toward shorter cooking time ~ 18 min). Or, you can double the cake recipe for an 8-inch, 3-layer cake (and lean toward longer cooking time ~ 21 min).Coffee Oreo Chocolate Cake with Salted Butterscotch Drip
Notes
Ingredients
For the cake: (6-inch triple layer)
For the frosting: (makes excess)
For the ganache: (makes just enough for this size)
For the salted bourbon butterscotch drip: (makes about double what you will need)
For assembly:
Instructions
Make the cake:
Make the frosting:
Make the ganache:
Make the butterscotch: (can be done in advance)
Assemble: